HEALTH ALERT: Children
Your Guide to Childrens' Health

Main Navigation

Sub-Navigation

Content

 
TOXIC PHTHALATES IN BABY CARE PRODUCTS

05FEB08

A study published in the medical journal Pediatrics studying babies in Los Angeles and two other U.S. cities, found that as the use of baby care products rose, so did the concentration of phthalates. Babies exposed to lotion, shampoo and powder had more than four times the level of phthalates in their urine as those whose parents had not used the products. Previous research found that the substances altered the children’s hormones (reduced testosterone in a 2006 study of newborns in Denmark) and reproductive organs.

Phthalates are a class of widely used industrial compounds known technically as dialkyl or alkyl aryl esters of 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid. One of the uses of this chemical is in baby products and children's toys; soften plastics; an additive in hairspray and perfume; and are even responsible for that 'new car smell'. Phthalates have been used in children's toys for quite some time. And children of course mouth toys constantly, especially toys made for oral use, like pacifiers and teething toys. But this study raises serious concerns for this chemical as an ingredient in baby products such as shampoos and lotions.

Phthalates are known as "endocrine disruptors" because they mimic the body's hormones. They are hormone-altering chemicals and have been linked to endocrine and reproductive system problems. Babies who are cared for with phthalate-laced products and cosmetics show developmental problems, especially in reproductive development of male children.

In the study, babies exposed to baby lotion, shampoo and powder had more than four times the level of phthalates in their urine than babies whose parents had not used the products. The highest levels were reported in babies under 8 months old, and those exposed to lotions. More than half the mothers in the new study reported using baby shampoos on their infants within 24 hours of the urine tests, and about one-third had used lotion, and 14% used powder within the same time period. The highest concentrations in the babies were for a phthalate known as MEP, which comes from DEP, the compound used in fragrances. No link was found to baby wipes or to diaper creams.

The lead scientist in the study, Dr. Sheela Sathyanarayana of the University of Washington's Department of Pediatrics, said the findings suggested that many baby care products contain a variety of phthalates that enter children's bodies through their skin. This is the first study to report this type of exposure. Previous studies have focused on a different route of exposure for children: sucking on soft, vinyl toys.

Representatives of the fragrance and cosmetics industries said they were surprised by the findings and questioned their validity. They said only one phthalate compound is used in baby products. Manufacturers do not list phthalates as ingredients on labels, so it is unknown which products contain them. Apparently, this policy needs to be revised.

Europe has banned some phthalates in baby toys and cosmetics, but not the DEP (diethyl phthalate) found in fragrances. A recently passed California law will ban six types in children's toys and feeding products, beginning next year. But no federal or state law in the United States prohibits their use in personal care products or cosmetics.

In their report, the scientists advised parents who want to reduce their baby's exposure to stop using lotions and powders unless their doctors recommend them for medical reasons. They also suggested limiting use of shampoos and other products. Many adult lotions and other personal care products also contain phthalates.

The Chicago Tribune cited a rash of studies about parabens - a common class of chemicals found in skin-care products, shampoos, conditioners, deodorants and other personal-care products. These preservatives are used to keep bacteria and other nasty things at bay while products sit on the shelves. Paraben is also found in human blood and urine, and has even been detected in breast tumors. Some forms of breast cancer have been linked to endocrine disruptors, though the specific culprit - or more likely conspiracy of culprits - has not been identified.

There are alternatives on the market that use natural alternatives. To find out if your products contain parabens, look for these product ingredients: methylparaben, ethylparaben, propylparaben or benzylparaben.

 
AVOIDING PHTHALATES & BABY CARE ALTERNATIVES

It’s a challenge to protect our children from the myriad of toxins in our modern world. In the wake of this news linking baby powder, lotion and shampoo to higher levels of phthalates in babies, many parents are looking for answers about avoiding products that contain them and alternatives to these baby products. Unfortunately, it's not easy to completely avoid phthalates.

  • Be wary of the term "fragrance," which is used to denote a combination of compounds, possibly including phthatates.
  • Use glass, instead of plastic containers. Look for the recycling codes that are on plastic products — the numbers 3 & 5 on a plastic container or toy means it’s vinyl or PVC and likely containing phthalates - they're products to AVOID.
  • Avoid products that list "parabens" as an ingredient on shampoos, conditioners and other personal care products. Some studies suggest these chemicals affect the reproductive and hormonal systems in animal tests.
  • Avoid products that list "sodium laurel/laureth sulfate" as an ingredient, because it contains a carcinogenic compound.
  • In regards to bathing your baby, plain water is all that you need. Special soaps and shampoos marketed for your baby are really just a cosmetic choice. With the exception of maybe excessively dry skin, most babies don’t need lotions or creams at all. Your baby's natural skin oils are all they need to keep moisturized
  • Buy organic as much as possible. If you’re concerned about diaper rashes, look for a non-petroleum, natural product. But natural soap and water is what you can use most of the time.
  • AVOID baby oil which clogs pores and damages skin. Vaseline and other petroleum-based lotions, gels and salves are also not safe for babies. Petroleum is a derivative of plastic and natural gas. In addition, many baby lotions contain large amounts of alcohol that dries skin and prevents healthy skin functioning. Some powders contain talc, which is actually a very soft type of rock. Baby shampoos and soaps are often just as harsh as adult shampoos and soaps.
  • A simple sponge bath or soak in warm water is all baby needs. For diapering, choose fragrance-free baby wipes with natural ingredients like aloe vera and vitamin E. Again, baby's skin is naturally soft. No lotion, cream or jelly is necessary to keep it that way.
  • If you want to powder your baby, use cornstarch. It absorbs moisture and soothes chaffing.
  • For diaper rash, make sure you are changing baby when needed. Let baby play without a diaper to air the rash. Make sure that the diaper rash is not Candida (a baby version of yeast infection). For Candida, apply fresh plain yogurt to the skin. If it is diaper rash, stop using all chemical products. Apply pure vitamin E and gently rub on skin. Burt's Bee's products are made with natural and safe ingredients and carry a complete line of baby products.
  • Also consider the oatmeal-based Aveeno products. These work well on serious skin conditions such as scabies and poison ivy/oak.